The St. Louis Board of Aldermen is currently considering a proposal that could introduce a new 3% fee on short-term rentals (STRs) in the city. This measure aims to address pressing issues related to affordable housing and homelessness while generating revenue to support local initiatives. As the city grapples with the implications of short-term rentals on its housing market, the proposed fee has sparked significant debate among lawmakers and residents alike.

The Context of Short-Term Rentals in St. Louis

In November 2023, St. Louis passed its first-ever short-term rental law, which established a framework for regulating STRs. Under this ordinance, short-term rentals are defined as residential occupancy of a rented dwelling for 30 days or less. Operators must obtain a city-issued permit for each property, with a maximum of four permits per individual. The law also mandates a $150 application fee and requires operators to designate a local agent available 24/7 to address any issues. Despite these regulations, the city has seen a significant rise in STRs, with over 1,300 properties listed on various platforms. This growth has raised concerns about the impact of short-term rentals on housing availability and neighborhood integrity, prompting the Board of Aldermen to consider additional measures.

The Proposed 3% Fee

The proposed 3% fee on short-term rentals would be presented to voters in November. The bill proposed by Narayan mandates that at least 50% of the funds collected be directed to the city's Affordable Housing Trust Fund, which supports organizations that build and repair homes for low- and middle-income residents, enhancing affordable housing availability. The remaining funds may support related initiatives, including a legal representation program for individuals facing eviction, championed by Aldermanic President Megan Green. This proposal aims to address St. Louis's affordable housing crisis by utilizing the city's growing short-term rental market to benefit residents. The bill's success now depends on voter approval, with hopes that it will foster a more inclusive and equitable housing landscape in the city. Alderman Bret Narayan, the bill’s sponsor, emphasized the need for this fee, stating, “Housing is essentially a zero-sum game. Every house that’s taken off the market to become a short-term rental is a house that a family or a member of our community cannot live in full time.” This proposal comes at a time when the city is facing challenges related to homelessness and housing affordability. The recent Supreme Court ruling allowing municipalities to enforce outdoor sleeping bans has intensified discussions about how to support vulnerable populations in St. Louis.

Community Response and Considerations

The potential fee has garnered mixed reactions from the community and local STR operators. Some property owners have expressed concerns that the fee may drive them out of the short-term rental market, pushing them to revert to traditional long-term leases. Others argue that the fee is a necessary step to ensure that the benefits of short-term rentals do not come at the expense of local residents' housing options. As the Board of Aldermen prepares to finalize the proposal, they are also considering the implications of a tight timeline. The city must certify ballot questions by late August for the November election, adding urgency to the discussions.

Conclusion

The ongoing debate in St. Louis regarding the proposed 3% fee on short-term rentals reflects a broader trend among cities grappling with the impact of STRs on local housing markets. As the Board of Aldermen weighs the potential benefits and drawbacks of this measure, the outcome could have significant implications for both property owners and residents. The decision will ultimately shape the future of short-term rentals in St. Louis, balancing the interests of the hospitality industry with the pressing need for affordable housing solutions.

​

For the latest news and updates, be sure to explore this website regularly. Staying informed will help you navigate the evolving landscape of vacation rental compliance and hosting effectively.