A 2024 Guide to Zoning for Vacation Rentals

Operating a vacation rental can be a lucrative venture, but before you dive in, there's one key challenge you need to master: zoning. Cities and municipalities often divide land into different categories based on intended use to regulate growth, protect property values, and maintain a community’s character. Zoning is essential, and it varies from city to city. Common classifications include residential, commercial, industrial, agricultural, and mixed-use zones, among others.

Understanding zoning laws is crucial for vacation rental hosts to avoid fines, penalties, or even forced closure of their properties. This guide breaks down the most common zoning types and how they apply to vacation rentals, ensuring you stay compliant and hassle-free.

Step 1: Get to Know Zoning Classifications for Vacation Rentals

Here’s an overview of the common zoning types and how vacation rentals (also known as short-term rentals or STRs) are permitted across various cities.

1. Agricultural Zones (AG or A)

Agricultural zones are primarily for farmland and rural areas, where urban development is restricted. However, short-term rentals can sometimes be allowed, particularly if they promote agritourism.

• In Austin, Texas, STRs are allowed in agricultural zones, provided they meet local regulations regarding property size and parking.
• Similarly, in San Luis Obispo County, California, vacation rentals are permitted with a special permit, especially for farm stays that align with promoting rural tourism.

2. Rural Zones (R or RU)

Rural zones typically encompass low-density residential areas, often on the city’s outskirts. Larger property sizes are common, and STRs are frequently permitted with specific conditions.

• In Sedona, Arizona, vacation rentals are allowed in rural residential zones, offering a peaceful countryside experience, regulated for noise and guest capacity.
• In San Bernardino County, California, STRs in rural zones need a special permit and must comply with fire safety and waste disposal regulations.

3. Residential Zones (R-1, R-2, R-3, etc.)

Residential zones are reserved for homes and dwellings, categorized into single-family (R-1), multi-family (R-2), and higher-density housing (R-3, R-4).

• In Los Angeles, California, STRs are allowed only if the property is the owner’s primary residence for at least 180 days a year, with restrictions on non-owner-occupied rentals.
• Nashville, Tennessee permits STRs in residential areas with a required permit but limits non-owner-occupied rentals to prevent neighborhood saturation.
• New Orleans, Louisiana allows STRs in residential zones but with strict caps on the number of rentals and necessary permits and taxes.

4. Commercial Zones (C-1, C-2, C-3, etc.)

Commercial zones are designed for businesses, retail, and hospitality. Vacation rentals are often a perfect fit for these zones, especially in tourist-heavy areas.

• In New York, STRs are allowed in commercial zones, particularly in neighborhoods with high tourist traffic, but restricted in residential zones.
• San Francisco, California permits STRs in commercial areas near business districts and cultural hubs, but they are heavily regulated in residential zones.

5. Mixed-Use Zones (MU or MX)

These zones blend residential and commercial use, common in urban neighborhoods where people live, shop, and work.

• In Portland, Oregon and Denver, Colorado, STRs are allowed with fewer restrictions, offering a balanced space for both living and business activities.

6. Resort or Tourist Zones (T or RT)

Designed to support tourism-related activities, these zones are often lenient on vacation rentals.

• In Maui, Hawaii and Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, STRs are not only allowed but encouraged to promote local tourism.

7. Industrial Zones (I-1, I-2, etc.)

Industrial zones are typically designated for factories and warehouses. STRs are usually prohibited, as in Chicago, Illinois, where such uses are incompatible with industrial activities.

8. Historic Zones

Historic zones aim to preserve neighborhoods with cultural significance, so STRs may be allowed but often face strict regulations.

• In Charleston, South Carolina, STRs need special permits to operate in historic zones.
• In Savannah, Georgia, STRs must follow occupancy and noise restrictions to preserve the area’s heritage.

9. Urban and Suburban Zones

Urban zones are high-density city areas, while suburban zones are lower-density regions often on city outskirts. STR regulations differ between these two.

• In Miami, Florida, STRs are permitted in urban areas but heavily regulated, particularly in Miami Beach, while suburban areas have more relaxed rules.
• Dallas, Texas permits STRs in both urban and suburban zones, though urban areas near downtown have stricter controls.

10. Special Use Districts

Special use districts are designed for specific activities such as entertainment or eco-friendly developments. STRs may or may not be allowed.

• In Las Vegas, STRs are permitted in certain entertainment districts but restricted in others.

Step 2: Categories of Zoning Use for Vacation Rentals

Once you understand zoning classifications, it’s essential to know the different categories of use for STRs in these zones.

1. Permitted Use

STRs can operate freely in these zones without special approval. This usually applies to Residential, Commercial, and Mixed-Use zones.

2. Conditional Use

STRs are allowed only if certain conditions are met, usually requiring a special permit or approval from the local zoning board.

• Common in Residential zones with restrictions, Historic districts, and Environmental zones where conservation is critical.

3. Accessory Use

STRs can operate as a secondary use, such as renting out a portion of the property while the owner lives in the main residence. This is typical in Single-Family Residential and Agricultural zones.

4. Prohibited Use

In some zones, STRs are entirely forbidden, usually in exclusive residential areas or environmentally protected zones.

5. Temporary Use

STRs are allowed for specific periods, such as during peak tourism seasons or special events, after which they revert to their original use.

6. Special Use Permits

For properties that fall outside standard zoning categories, a special use permit can be granted, usually after a public hearing.

Step 3: Research Local Zoning Regulations

Each city and county has its own set of zoning laws. Here's how to stay informed:

• Check local government websites for zoning maps and regulations.
• Contact the planning department for detailed insights.
• Use tools like Lodge Compliance to automatically track zoning laws and avoid fines.

Step 4: Determine If You Need a Zoning Permit or License

Some areas require specific zoning permits, separate from short-term rental licenses. Ensure compliance by obtaining the necessary permits, or consult Lodge Compliance for assistance in streamlining the process.

Step 5: Stay Updated on Local Ordinances

Zoning laws can change frequently, especially in areas with growing tourism. Subscribe to government newsletters or use compliance tools like Lodge Compliance to stay ahead of regulatory shifts.

Step 6: Handle Non-Compliant Situations

If your property falls in a zone where STRs are restricted or prohibited, consider:

• Applying for a variance to deviate from zoning requirements.
• Reclassifying your property if eligible.
• Exploring legal alternatives, such as long-term rentals or other business models.

Mastering Zoning with Lodge Compliance

Navigating zoning laws for vacation rentals doesn’t have to be stressful. With knowledge and the right tools like Lodge Compliance, you can ensure your property remains compliant and your business runs smoothly. From automatic updates to zoning law tracking, Lodge Compliance simplifies the entire process for you.

‍